Indian Recruiting Scam?

Submitted by Flecknoe on Fri, 2007-05-25 22:51.
Rating

Myself, in Pittsburgh, and a friend, in Houston, have been receiving an increasing number of inquiries about contract/contract-to-hire/permanent jobs in the Technical Writing field lately from recruiters around the country that seem to be ACTUALLY based in India.

When I receive an inquiry from a recruiter in broken English, whether by email or by phone, it immediately raises my hackles. Generally, the emails are poorly written and provide no detail of the specific job. The phone numbers are either "Private" or when reverse searched generally turn out to be cell phones.

When an email lists a phone number and a fax number, they usually are from different area codes and states. The majority of the phone numbers seem to be in New Jersey. Most of the websites seem, if reviewed without skepticism, to be somewhat legitimate. A deeper investigation into the actual owners of the companies and/or websites, however, usually results in dead ends.

In my dealings with any of these recruiters, I generally have suggested to them that they buy a map. I don't see relocating for a 3-month contract position at below-market rates; and I certainly have no intention of commuting 300 or more miles. I suppose if you lived in Rhode Island, anywhere in the state would be "nearby".

I at first sent resumes to these recruiters naively assuming that they had genuine positions for which I might be qualified. It finally dawned on me that once I sent my resume, 75% never contacted me again. Another 10% contacted me once to ask further questions. An additional 10% contacted me repeatedly saying I was being submitted for a job in another city. And 5% contacted me and changed their story regarding the rate of pay for the job.

Can anyone out there tell me what exactly these people are doing with our resumes? It is my firm belief that they actually have no connection to any legitimate employer. I believe any positions that they actually post on any of the job boards are merely copies of someone else's legitimate posting. When they attempt to reword it, they generally fail miserably at maintaining the integrity of the job description.

Why are they doing this? What do they stand to gain? I can't even see it as possible identity theft because all they have is a work history, a name, an address, and phone numbers.

Thanks for any explanation that you can offer.

P.S. - I may have a story in the near future regarding one of these so-called agencies. It seems a number of them list "business partners" on their sites and many of these companies are totally unaware of said relationship. I have a friend involved with a business partner investigating.

( categories: | )

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by drewzhrodague on Sat, 2007-05-26 16:01.

ACtually, I have also been contacted by an Indian guy with badly broken English about a position in Pittsburgh. The guy is actually incoherent, does not answer direct questions, and will just repeat that he has a position in Pittsburgh, and that I am highly skilled. The guy claims to be from ACCoy, but his phone number is from a 248 or 246 area code.

Since he mentioned that he was from ACCoy, I told him that I didn't want to do business with them at all, and why. I had to speak very slowly and very loudly in order to get him to stop reading me the same parts of the script he had. I eventually had to hang up on him. Then he called me the next day. And the next!!!

Submitted by drewzhrodague on Thu, 2007-05-31 20:21.

On Slashdot today is an article about a new rash of bad recruiting tactics. I didn't get a chance to do frist psot, so I figured I'd just link here. This is something that we've been talking about for some time here -- bad recruiters, and their bad tactics.

Submitted by csmap on Mon, 2007-08-06 21:43.

I was scammed by a top-tier out-outsouring company, hiring those who speak American English, fishing for resume at job searaching wedsite(s), deploying bait and switch tatics. Low, very low.

Live Free or Die Hard !

Submitted by IamLostRU on Fri, 2007-10-26 14:03.

After getting involved with an insistant email string with a seemingly diligent, but hard to understand (with shall we say uncommon grammar), recruiter who could not understand that Indiana was not a reasonable commute from New Jersey, I discovered, from the Company he was referring me to:

There is apparently a business idea where these in India recruiters run some type of match programs through all the on line resumes. Not unlike other recruiters I guess. They are allowed to submit the candidiate to the company and be the recruiter of record. However, they only charge a small percent of the normal fee.

By the way, this particular one, was not allowed to call me..as he told me they were "virtual recruiters based in India". Now I must say, the ideas isn't terrible...the execution wasn't effective...but they were honest...after a bit of pushing...about what they were up to.

Submitted by Gryffyx on Sun, 2007-10-28 19:00.

The influx of Indian recruiters is really beginning to make for a lot of background noise - I can't recall how many letters I've received recently from recruiters like this. Everything from the next state to India is the location for these short-term contract positions.
I guess, on a cosmic scale, I should be able to step out of my door in the midwestern USM and walk into Bangalore for work that morning.